|  
               
            Web Exclusives: More 
             
            
            May 16, 2001: 
               Nassau 
              Hall, Princeton, New Jersey 
            By Sean Wilentz, Dayton-Stockton 
              professor of history at Nassau Hall. See related feature 
            From the Book American 
              Places: Encounters With History, edited by William E. Leuchtenburg, 
              copyright - 2000 by Oxford University Press, Inc. Used by permission 
              of Oxford University Press, Inc. 
             
            In June 1956, Edmund Wilson, 
              Class of 1916, returned to Princeton University to receive an honorary 
              degree, in conjunction with the fortieth anniversary of his class's 
              graduation and the bicentennial of Nassau Hall. The occasion was 
              slightly awkward. Wilson had great affection for his old college, 
              and especially for the memory of his departed teachers Norman Kemp 
              Smith and Christian Gauss. A few years earlier, when presiding over 
              a set of the prestigious Princeton seminars named in Gauss's honor 
              - and presenting work that would eventually wind up as part of his 
              monumental study, Patriotic Gore, edited by another Princeton graduate, 
              Sheldon Meyer - Wilson one day took his friend Leon Edel on a private 
              tour of his former stomping grounds, enthusiastically showing off 
              the architectural highlights. But Wilson had never partaken of the 
              rah-rah bonhomie for which Princeton graduates were, and are, so 
              famous. And more than a few Princetonians regarded Wilson - the 
              bookish, oft-married ex-radical and (thanks to Memoirs of Hecate 
              County) reputed pornographer - as a disloyal odd duck. 
            Wilson and his latest (and 
              last) wife, Elena, sensed the underlying tension. The day before 
              the big event, from their guest quarters, they could hear the nearby 
              banging of the carpenters who were erecting the ceremonial graduation 
              stage and dais outside Nassau Hall. 
            "Come and look, dear," Mrs. 
              Wilson remarked (or words to that effect). "They're building your 
              scaffold." 
            Of course, Princeton did 
              not hang Wilson, even metaphorically, but honored him. And so, outside 
              Nassau Hall, tension gave way to paradox. Wilson was never shy about 
              showing his disdain for the American academy and for what he regarded 
              as its obscurantist obsessions. He did teach now and again, to help 
              make ends meet (though his monotone lecturing style turned off his 
              audiences in droves). Otherwise, he said, "writers are much better 
              off outside colleges." And yet, there he stood, the supposedly defiant 
              freelance man of letters, happily picking up another Princeton degree 
              in front of the most storied academic building in the United States, 
              two hundred years after its completion. 
            It was not the first ironic 
              moment, nor would it be the last, in the sometimes unfortunate history 
              of Nassau Hall. 
            To walk past Nassau Hall, 
              as I do two or three times each workday, gives only the slightest 
              hints of that history. With its massive brown stone outer walls, 
              the place appears to have been there forever. Dominating the university's 
              Front Campus, it looks, to any well-traveled academic, like the 
              quintessential college administrative headquarters: imposing, serene, 
              and official. (Even the bronze tigers that guard the main entrance 
              are at ease.) Apart from small knots of tourists being led around 
              campus by one of the university tour guides, no one ever seems to 
              enter or exit Nassau Hall. The life of the campus is elsewhere, 
              around the classrooms and dormitories, where gaggles of undergraduates, 
              women and men - including, in good weather, the Frisbee players 
              - are perpetually in motion: Nassau Hall is more like a machine 
              that quietly goes of itself. The building is certainly important, 
              especially to a Princeton faculty member, as the Place Where Big 
              Decisions Are Made. But in its tranquil self-assurance, it betrays, 
              at a glance, little of its turbulent - and sometimes paradoxical 
              - past. 
            While it was still under 
              construction, the place came perilously close to being named Belcher 
              Hall. In 1747, Jonathan Belcher, a devout Massachusetts Congregationalist, 
              was chosen royal governor of New Jersey, and he immediately made 
              a pet project of supporting the fledgling College of New Jersey, 
              then located in Elizabeth. Belcher was shocked at the degraded spiritual 
              condition of Harvard and Yale - where, he said, he had reason to 
              believe that "Arminianism, Arianism and even Socinianism, in destruction 
              of the doctrines of free grace are daily propagated" - and he saw 
              the New Jersey seminary as a potential bulwark of the Lord. Seven 
              years later, when work began on the college's new building in Princeton, 
              the trustees tried to honor the governor for his support by naming 
              it after him. ("And when your Excellency is translated into a house 
              not made with hands, eternal in the Heavens," the trustees entreated 
              him, "let Belcher Hall proclaim your beneficent acts.") Belcher 
              graciously declined, and suggested instead the name Nassau Hall, 
              dedicated "to the immortal memory of the glorious King William III, 
              who was a branch of the illustrious house of Nassau." Thus, thanks 
              to Belcher's modesty, began the tradition that in later decades 
              would lead to the composing of "Old Nassau" - imagine a school song 
              entitled "Old Belcher" - as well as to the adoption of orange and 
              black as Princeton's official colors. 
            The village of Princeton 
              had been chosen as the college's new home in part because of its 
              proximity to New Light Calvinist Pennsylvania, Delaware, and Maryland, 
              and in part because of its salubrious location on a high ridge, 
              well protected from the then-fearsome New Jersey mosquito. For the 
              new college building, the trustees wanted the finest and most imposing 
              design they could find. A basic plan, offered by the trustee Edward 
              Shippen in 1753, called for a structure 190 feet long and 50 feet 
              deep. Thereafter, Shippen's brother, Dr. William Shippen, in collaboration 
              with the distinguished Philadelphia architect Robert Smith (who 
              had designed Carpenter's Hall, later the meeting place of the First 
              Continental Congress), translated the rough plan into a formal proposal. 
              The cornerstone was laid on September 17, 1754, and for nearly two 
              years workmen raised the walls of local stone and then plastered 
              the interior. In November 1756, as the finishing touches were still 
              being applied, the College of New Jersey officially moved in, claiming 
              an edifice that, though fourteen feet shorter than Edward Shippen's 
              original outline had dictated, still impressed the trustees as "the 
              most spacious on the continent." 
            A huge, stylistically up-to-date, 
              Georgian pitched-roof building, the original Nassau Hall was gracious 
              as well as spacious, more so than its later remodeled versions. 
              In contrast to the Old World universities, wrote the college's president 
              Aaron Burr Senior, "[w]e do everything in the plainest ... manner,... 
              having no superfluous ornaments." A depiction of the head of Homer 
              did dominate the flat arch above the building's central doorway, 
              and some decorative urns appeared on the central facade, but otherwise 
              the building had a remarkable lightness for all its solidity, topped 
              off by a bell-tower cupola patterned after the upper part of the 
              cupola of the recently built St. Mary- le-Strand in London, much 
              better proportioned than the current structure. 
            Befitting the college's primary 
              function as a trainer of clergy, the original Nassau Hall was a 
              place of devotion as well as of instruction. After entering the 
              central doorway, one passed into a hallway that led straight to 
              the Prayer Hall, flanked on either side by classrooms. Here, in 
              the unheated north end of what is now the Faculty Room, students 
              would be summoned by the cupola bell at the crack of dawn for morning 
              worship - an exercise (especially during winter) of bone-chilling 
              piety that did not sit well with later, more secular generations 
              of undergraduates. Below, in the basement, were the kitchen, dining 
              room, and steward's quarters. On the second floor, in a single room, 
              was the library, above which were two rooms probably used for recitations. 
              The building's wings consisted of small suites, most of which included 
              a bedroom and two tiny studies. In 1762, an increase in student 
              enrollment necessitated the completion of student chambers in the 
              basement - gloomy, damp rooms that housed the unluckiest of the 
              first-year pupils. 
            Like an Anglo-American cloister, 
              the early Nassau Hall almost completely enclosed college life. Here, 
              the college's tutors as well as its students slept, ate, prayed, 
              and attended class. (Only the college president was permitted separate 
              quarters, in a Philadelphia Georgian dwelling, also designed by 
              Robert Smith.) Yet no sooner was the all-encompassing edifice completed 
              than bad fortune descended on the college. 
            In February 1757, President 
              Burr had to step in to fulfill the duties of one of the college's 
              tutors, the Rev. Caleb Smith, who had fallen ill. Six months later, 
              Burr, worn out from overwork, presided extemporaneously at Smith's 
              funeral; then, after a taxing trip to Philadelphia, Burr rode north 
              to Elizabeth to preach a funeral sermon for the suddenly departed 
              Governor Belcher. Finally, himself overtaken by a raging fever, 
              Burr weakened and died on September 24. Five days later, the trustees 
              named Burr's eminent father-in-law, the renowned Massachusetts evangelist 
              and theologian Jonathan Edwards, as Burr's successor. 
            In January 1758, Edwards 
              arrived at the President's House to great acclaim from the tutors 
              and students. Unfortunately, smallpox was prevalent in Princeton 
              that year, and Edwards, who had never been exposed, decided to submit 
              to an inoculation from the same Dr. William Shippen who had had 
              a hand in designing Nassau Hall. The inoculation did not take, and 
              on March 22, the great Edwards died. His successor, Samuel Davies, 
              was young, eloquent, and learned - but he had also, for years, suffered 
              from tuberculosis, a condition the trustees apparently overlooked. 
              After punishing himself with a dawn-to-midnight work schedule, the 
              dedicated President Davies died after a little more than a year's 
              service. For the third time in the five years since relocating to 
              Princeton, the college solemnly buried its president in the old 
              cemetery down the road from Nassau Hall. 
            Here, seemingly, was providence 
              ill enough to chill any Calvinist's soul. Supposedly wholesome Princeton 
              had become a president's graveyard. Davies's death, one correspondent 
              reported, "spread a gloom all over the country" and plunged the 
              college into despair. 
            It was only under the leadership 
              of the eminent Scots emigrÈ and eventual American patriot 
              John Witherspoon, who served as president from 1768 until 1794, 
              that the College of New Jersey truly began to flourish. Witherspoon 
              steadied the institution's finances, increased its endowment, and 
              ventilated Its curriculum with the bracing ideas of the Scottish 
              Enlightenment. Before Witherspoon's arrival, the college's scientific 
              equipage was sorely lacking, especially in comparison to Harvard 
              (which boasted numerous stuffed birds and animals, the skull of 
              an Indian warrior, and the tanned skin of an unidentified Negro); 
              but beginning with the purchase of the famed astronomer David Rittenhouse's 
              intricate orrery (a sort of miniature planetarium, installed in 
              Nassau Hall in 1770, Witherspoon quickly closed the gap. Under Witherspoon, 
              the college also generated a hot republican spirit, carried forth 
              into the American Revolution by, among others, three illustrious 
              members of the class of 1771: Hugh Henry Brackenridge, Philip Freneau, 
              and, most auspiciously, James Madison. Witherspoon himself signed 
              the Declaration of Independence in 1776. Under Witherspoon, Nassau 
              Hall even served temporarily, in 1783, as the new nation's capitol. 
              Yet it was also under Witherspoon (and because of the Revolution) 
              that Nassau Hall suffered the first of a succession of devastating 
              physical blows. And for several years, immediately after the Declaration 
              of Independence, it seemed that the new nation's good fortune was 
              the college's bad fortune-and vice versa.  
            On December 7, 1776, British 
              forces, fresh from their victories over General Washington's troops 
              in New York, occupied Princeton and commenced what one eyewitness 
              called the "twenty days tyranny." Redcoats pillaged and burned the 
              town's great houses; and suspected rebels wound up imprisoned inside 
              an abandoned Nassau Hall, where a regiment of regulars had taken 
              up quarters, ravaged the library, and turned the basement into a 
              horse stable. Even worse was yet to come. Washington's men rallied 
              on the other side of the Delaware River, and on January 3, 1777, 
              after an all-night march from Trenton, they inflicted their famous 
              disastrous defeat on the British about a mile outside Princeton 
              village. Some of the fleeing British regulars took refuge in Nassau 
              Hall, knocked out windows, and prepared to counterattack- but Washington's 
              artillery hit the building with such lethal force that the British 
              were forced to surrender. (Gouges caused by the cannonade can still 
              be seen on the buildings south exterior wall.) Toward the end of 
              the fighting, a rebel cannonball flew through one of the Prayer 
              Hall windows and smashed the college's portrait of King George II- 
              the signal, legend has it, that led the redcoats to lay down their 
              arms. 
            Though returned to patriot 
              hands, Princeton was a wreck. ("You would think it had been desolated 
              with the plague and an earthquake Benjamin Rush observed; "the college 
              and church are heaps of ruins, all the inhabitants have been plundered.") 
              And for Nassau Hall, Washington's victory proved a prelude for further 
              depredations. American soldiers took up residence and stayed for 
              five months, turning benches and doors into firewood, stripping 
              the walls of plaster, destroying the college organ, and covering 
              the floors with what one report politely called "an accumulation 
              of... filth." Rittenhouse's orrery, which the British had carefully 
              preserved along with the rest of the college's scientific instruments, 
              became a plaything for the idle Americans and wound up so severely 
              damaged that it could not be fully repaired. When the troops departed 
              in October 1777, doctors converted Nassau Hall into a military hospital 
              where, for over a year, ill and wounded men tried to recover amid 
              the squalid debris. 
            Slowly- and, in view of what 
              had happened, miraculously- the college also recovered. President 
              Witherspoon, who served in the Continental Congress in Philadelphia 
              from 1776 until 1782, returned to Princeton as often as he could, 
              and with the assistance of one tutor and one professor of mathematics, 
              he oversaw the resumption of classes in nearby private homes during 
              the summer of 1777. Witherspoon also handed Congress a bill for 
              the damage inflicted on college property, and by the end of 1779, 
              he had actually managed to collect nearly twenty thousand dollars 
              in Continental currency. Yet by the time the money arrived, it had 
              so depreciated in value that it could barely cover the cost of patching 
              Nassau Hall's roof, replacing the broken windows, and making stopgap 
              repairs to the classrooms and student living quarters. In May 1782, 
              a newly enrolled student remarked that, inside and out, the building 
              remained badly scarred by the war, with two of its four floors "a 
              heap of ruins." 
            Local spirits revived in 
              1783, at a perilous moment for the republic. Menaced by a massed 
              body of mutinous, unpaid Continental soldiers, Congress fled Philadelphia 
              and, at the instigation of their president, Elias Boudinot (a College 
              of New Jersey trustee), the members reconvened in Nassau Hall's 
              barely restored library room. During the war, the British had twice 
              forced Congress to leave Philadelphia; but now, two years after 
              the British surrender at Yorktown and with a peace treaty in negotiation, 
              internal discord sent the representatives packing. For four months 
              (until Congress relocated yet again to Annapolis, Maryland), the 
              New Jersey crossroads village and its battered college served as 
              the capital of the United States- an embarrassment that made it 
              difficult to gather a quorum of seven states, let alone the nine 
              states required by the Articles of Confederation to ratify a treaty. 
            Despite the immense difficulties, 
              for representatives and townsmen alike, the interlude greatly improved 
              Princeton's morale. Once they had settled in, the temporary congressional 
              residents found the place suitable, even attractive. ("With respect 
              to situation, convenience & pleasure, I do not know a more agreeable 
              spot in America," Charles Thompson, the Congress's secretary, wrote 
              to his wife, Hannah.) And tutors, students, and townsmen got to 
              share in the excitement of a rousing official Fourth of July celebration, 
              the arrival of George Washington in August for a two-month stay, 
              and, at the end of October, the receipt of the exultant report that 
              the Treaty of Paris had, at last, been signed. "The face of things 
              inconceivably altered," the young student Ashbel Green later commented, 
              amid "the passing and rattling of wagons, coaches, and chairs, the 
              crying about of pine apples, oranges, lemons and every luxurious 
              article." After attending the college's September commencement ceremony, 
              General Washington presented the trustees with a personal donation 
              of fifty guineas. The trustees, much encouraged, duly commissioned 
              Charles Willson Peale to paint a portrait of Washington, which still 
              hangs in the Faculty Room, surrounded by the same frame that had 
              contained the battle-destroyed picture of George II. 
            Congress proved much less 
              grateful than Washington and repeatedly rejected Witherspoon's requests 
              for additional appropriations to restore Nassau Hall. In a preview 
              of Princeton strategies to come, Witherspoon instead turned to graduates 
              and friends of the college for support. He raised more than seventeen 
              hundred pounds, a respectable sum considering the hard times (though, 
              once again, currency depreciation sharply curtailed the collected 
              money's actual value by the time it arrived in Princeton). With 
              the return of fee-paying pupils, along with occasional gifts from 
              graduates, Witherspoon was able to lay aside enough cash to commence 
              rebuilding in earnest. In 1794, the year Witherspoon died, the French 
              traveler Moreau de Saint-Mery remarked that the college's courtyard 
              looked "dirty and unkempt," and that the enclosure wall was in "a 
              deplorable state." Still, the third floor of Nassau Hall had been 
              restored, its roof completely replaced, and its floors and windows 
              repaired. Inside the students' chambers there were new bedsteads 
              and tables; and the hall's interior walls, partitions, and stairways 
              were all thoroughly reclaimed. In 1800 student enrollment climbed 
              above one hundred, and the trustees had to refurbish the basement 
              rooms in Nassau Hall's perennially wet west wing, in order to accommodate 
              "the expected additions." There was even talk of enlarging the faculty 
              with new endowed professorships and of erecting additional buildings. 
            "Every sign pointed to a 
              continued rapid growth," noted the university's later official historian, 
              T. J. Wertenbaker. Then, disaster struck again. 
            At one o'clock in the afternoon 
              on March 6, 1802, as students were filing into Nassau Hall for their 
              midday meal, a fire broke out in the belfry. A senior named George 
              Strawbridge rushed upstairs and unsuccessfully tried to quench the 
              blaze with a pitcher of water, while other students and teachers 
              grabbed what books, furniture, clothing, and personal effects they 
              could carry away. By evening, all but a hundred of the college library's 
              three thousand volumes had been destroyed, and Nassau Hall stood 
              a blackened hulk. President Witherspoon's successor, the devout 
              Samuel Stanhope Smith, had no doubt that one or more members of 
              the college's small knot of freethinking Jacobinical pupils had 
              been responsible. ("This is the progress of vice and irreligion," 
              Smith exclaimed as the fire was spreading.) In fact, a neglectful 
              chimney sweep appears to have been at fault. But the trustees, goaded 
              by Smith, summarily suspended a group of "undesirable characters" 
              suspected of foul play. 
            Smith's judgment was just 
              as swift - and much less questionable - about rebuilding Nassau 
              Hall. While the students lived and attended class in local homes 
              and boardinghouses, Smith left the supervision of the college to 
              subordinates and spent more than a year canvassing wealthy graduates 
              for contributions to a rebuilding fund. His efforts, along with 
              those of several trustees, quickly raised considerable cash, and 
              the college commissioned the distinguished Philadelphia architect 
              Benjamin Latrobe to commence reconstruction plans. Latrobe made 
              some minor alterations, enlarging the cupola, installing new pediments 
              over the three front doors, and paving the hallway floors with brick. 
              (Unfortunately, Latrobe's major contribution, a new iron roof, proved 
              so leaky that it had to be replaced completely.) But because the 
              building's massive original walls had survived the destruction, 
              Latrobe decided against completely overhauling the place in his 
              preferred Classical Revival style, and Nassau Hall retained its 
              essentially Georgian character. The fund-raising efforts, meanwhile, 
              proved bounteous enough to break ground for two entirely new structures 
              - the Philosophical Building (on the site of the present Chancellor 
              Green Library), which housed the college kitchen, dining hall, recitation 
              rooms, and the observatory, and the still - extant Stanhope Hall, 
              set aside for study halls, a new college library, and rooms for 
              the college's two literary societies. 
            A student rebellion five 
              years after the disastrous fire caused temporary damage to Nassau 
              Hall and lasting damage to the college. In March 1807, three students 
              were suspended, one for getting drunk in a local tavern, one for 
              cursing and insulting a tutor, and one for insulting Professor of 
              Chemistry John Maclean, frequenting taverns, and "bringing strong 
              liquor into the college." Convinced that the suspensions were based 
              on partial and prejudiced evidence, the accused students' friends 
              organized a petition drive, which wound up leading to the suspension 
              of 125 additional students - roughly three fourths of the entire 
              student body. The same night that the penalties were announced, 
              the discharged pupils ransacked Nassau Hall, warding off alarmed 
              tutors and townsmen with bludgeons fashioned from the building's 
              banisters. 
            President Smith immediately 
              canceled the classes that remained before the five-week spring vacation; 
              and in due course, with peace restored, fifty-five of the rebels 
              were readmitted. (One of those who was not, Abel P. Upshur of Virginia, 
              went on to become secretary of state under President John Tyler, 
              only to get blown to pieces in 1844 when a cannon on a great ship 
              he was inspecting - eerily, the USS Princeton - unexpectedly exploded). 
              "We will probably have fewer students," one trustee wrote in the 
              aftermath of the riot, "but a few under discipline is better than 
              a mob without any." The first part of this prediction proved true 
              - by 1812, the student body had shrunk to fewer than one hundred, 
              down from the nearly two hundred students enrolled in 18o6-7 - but 
              the result was penury and stagnation. Pious families feared Nassau 
              Hall was too licentious for their offspring; others feared it was 
              too draconian; and college receipts rapidly dwindled. Thereafter, 
              the college entered nearly two decades of institutional and intellectual 
              decline, a period that Wertenbaker described as "Princeton's nadir." 
            The turning point - arguably 
              the most important moment in the college's early institutional history 
              - came in 1826, when a group of loyal graduates organized the Alumni 
              Association of Nassau Hall. After electing the aging James Madison 
              as their president, the members dedicated themselves to promoting 
              the interests of the college - including expanding its endowment 
              - and scheduled annual campus reunions at commencement time. The 
              formation of the association was to have a lasting impact on the 
              sum and substance of Princeton life, giving the alumni an unusually 
              close connection to the college's continuing development and originating 
              the annual reunion celebrations that, over the years, have become 
              spectacles of great iconographic (and even anthropological) interest 
              to observers of elite American mores. More immediately, the association 
              raised the money needed for Princeton's first great period of physical 
              and intellectual expansion, including the hiring of new distinguished 
              faculty to endowed professorships (none more celebrated than Joseph 
              Henry, professor of natural philosophy) and, in time, the erection 
              of two new dormitories, dubbed, respectively, East and West College. 
            Nassau Hall (which gained 
              the nickname North College) was dingy and drafty compared to the 
              newly built dorms, but into the 1850s it kept its reputation as 
              the "swell" residence on campus. Aside from the somewhat larger 
              cupola, it would have seemed little changed to anyone who had seen 
              the original as constructed a century earlier. But in March 1855, 
              yet another fire, this one starting in a student's room on the second 
              floor, reduced the place once again to nothing more than its exterior 
              walls. President John Maclean Jr., in office for less than a year, 
              following his predecessor Stanhope's example, turned to the alumni 
              for rebuilding funds, and looked to Philadelphia for an architect. 
              Unfortunately, Princeton's choice, the fashionable designer John 
              Notman, was far less circumspect than Latrobe had been, and he initiated 
              an architectural vandalizing of Nassau Hall more damaging than anything 
              the redcoats and rebels of 1777 or the hothead students of 1807 
              could have imagined. 
            Notman was a champion of 
              the Florentine Italianate Revival style, first made popular by Queen 
              Victoria's Osborne House on the Isle of Wight and imitated thereafter, 
              in the 1850s and 1860s, by mansion owners and church builders all 
              across England and the United States. Notman himself had brought 
              the style to Princeton with his design for the Prospect mansion 
              on the old Morgan estate near the college (later the president's 
              house, and currently the university's faculty and staff club); and 
              when given the commission to remodel Nassau Hall, he tried his best 
              to turn the old Georgian pile into a squat, squared-off, archwindowed 
              imitation Tuscan villa. He was restrained by the college's demand 
              that he utilize the surviving original walls; otherwise, though, 
              he let his imagination run wild. The old central doorway was replaced 
              by an arched stone entrance, above which Notman built a stone balcony 
              with a large arched window. At either end of the building, he added 
              square Italianate towers, both of them rising a full story's height 
              above the roofline. Atop the entire building he placed a new cupola, 
              much larger than its predecessors, that utterly dominated the building 
              beneath it. 
            Notman also changed the building's 
              interior. The old staircases flanking the central entrance were 
              replaced by winding red-stone steps in the new towers. Partitions 
              arose across the east and west hallways, in order to discourage 
              student pranksters and rioters; new hallways connected adjacent 
              rooms to create single rooms; a new library room was placed on the 
              building's south end; and the entire place was joisted with galvanized 
              iron as a fireproofing precaution. The improvements, especially 
              in the spacious new library, were obvious; and when workmen hung 
              Peale's portrait of Washington (which had been rescued yet again 
              from the flames) on the library's north wall, a clear connection 
              was made with the old Nassau Hall. But when students finally returned 
              in August 1856, they occupied a very different structure from the 
              one completed exactly one hundred years earlier. 
            Nassau Hall's second century, 
              from John Notman's restoration to the awarding of Edmund Wilson's 
              honorary degree, was much less turbulent than the first - and, architecturally, 
              much kinder. During the decades after the Civil War, the building 
              of additional dormitories led to the departure of the resident undergraduates, 
              replaced first by museums and laboratories and, after the completion 
              of Palmer Laboratory and Guyot Hall in 1909, by academic administrators. 
              (John Grier Hibben, president from 1912 until 1932, was the first 
              president to have his office in Nassau Hall; and beginning in 1924, 
              the building was devoted completely to offices of the university's 
              central administration.) Notman's most egregious error, the brooding 
              Italianate towers at the building's eastern and western ends, was 
              partially corrected in 1905, when the tops of the towers were cut 
              down to conform with the main building's roofline. (Notman's grandiose 
              cupola had been earlier improved by the installation of a fourfaced 
              neo-Georgian clock in 1876, a donation from the Class of 1866 in 
              honor of their tenth reunion.) 
            The outstanding positive 
              contribution of the 1856 restoration, the new college library, was 
              rendered superfluous when the nearby Chancellor Green Library was 
              completed in 1873. After serving for more than thirty years as the 
              college museum, the room was handed over in 1906 to the firm of 
              Day and Klauder, which designed the impressive Faculty Room. Modeled 
              on the British House of Commons, the room is still used for faculty 
              meetings, debates, and official convocations. Thirteen years later, 
              in the patriotic aftermath of World War I, Day and Klauder also 
              redesigned the entrance hall as a marble memorial to Princeton's 
              war dead, beginning with the names of ten ex-students killed in 
              the American Revolution. 
            Decorative elements also 
              sprouted up outside Nassau Hall, at odds with President Burr's old 
              admonition against "superfluous ornaments," but not with the building's 
              basic integrity. Beginning some time in the 1860s or 1870s, successive 
              groups of graduating seniors have planted ivy around the building's 
              wall, marked off by discrete inscribed stone tablets.' In 1879, 
              the graduating seniors - including one Thomas Woodrow Wilson - presented 
              a pair of sculpted lions (adapted from the House of Nassau's crest) 
              to guard the hall's entryway. Thirty-two years later, when the lions 
              were much the worse for wear - and by which time, worse still, the 
              tiger and not the lion had become Princeton's mascot - the same 
              class donated the two recumbent, placid bronze tigers, designed 
              by the renowned sculptor A. P. Proctor, that continue to adorn the 
              main entryway. 
            A year after Proctor's tigers 
              appeared, President Hibben, the first president to move his office 
              into Nassau Hall, was inaugurated - and the young Edmund Wilson 
              arrived for his freshman year. A generation later, when Wilson received 
              his honorary degree, Nassau Hall was virtually unchanged. And so, 
              apart from some interior and minor exterior alterations finished 
              in 1967, Nassau Hall remains the same today. 
            Time has softened most of 
              the old wounds, including the self-inflicted ones. Not that the 
              old spirit of unrest has completely departed. By moving the administration's 
              nerve center to Nassau Hall, the university (so renamed in 1896) 
              ensured that, from time to time, Nassau Hall would be a staging 
              ground for protests, by activist students (most notably over the 
              war in Vietnam in the 1960s and over Princeton's investments in 
              South Africa fifteen years later) and, more decorously, by complaining 
              faculty members (over the entire panoply of university issues). 
            Still, the prevailing note 
              today is of sturdiness and tranquility. It takes some historical 
              research, and a little historical imagination, to see beyond all 
              that to a deeper appreciation of what the building has been through, 
              and what it stands for. No longer the largest structure in town, 
              dwarfed by the towers of Gothic dormitories and postwar science 
              labs, Nassau Hall is, on close inspection, far more than an administration 
              building: it is a battle-scarred monument to the university's - 
              and the nation'scontinuities and changes. As I pass by and see it, 
              artificially illuminated, at workday's end, it glows as an emblem 
              of Princeton's better nature, which is to be (as Woodrow Wilson 
              proclaimed in 1896) a university "in the nation's service." 
            Inside the truncated unfortunate 
              Italianate towers, countless footfalls have worn down the stone 
              steps into venerable slopes, blending in with the genuine Georgian 
              surroundings. And, from a distance, even Notman's cupola looks more 
              graceful with the passing of years, vaulting above the small forest 
              of the Front Campus, breaking through the modern car-infested clamor 
              of Nassau and Witherspoon streets, beckoning to what Edmund Wilson 
              called the "languid amenities" of a place of great privilege and 
              great learning. 
 |